Cookie's Uncensored Reviews 🔒

I use cursing only like 20% of the time I speak :smiley: No worries.

1 Like

@LillyR - The Wedding Buddies


1st Episode

  • Her dad is so real, it’s depressive. :neutral_face:
  • So far I really have no comments, since directing is smooth, and dialogues are great. My only small issue so far is the use of non-talking animations for dialogue lines, mostly these were laugh animations. I’d suggest putting laugh before/after the dialogue lines.
  • Good job, I can’t stand MC’s mom and sister and it’s been like 2 minutes :smiley:
  • My OCD-ish habits just don’t like how you zoomed on MC when she speaks to Stella. You cut off some part of her head and it’s making me anxious.

I think this is the least I wrote for the 1st episode for anyone’s story. I honestly loved it. Directing is flawless, like not a single mistake. And dialogues are so natural I’m just… Crying my happy tears. There were 2 things only mentioned, and of course, I’d be happy to see them gone :DDDDD But your story is great regardless.


2nd Episode

  • What? Why did she run away? :smiley:
  • I was dying to tell MC’s mom all that stuff. Jeez.
  • Why is Stella such a bitch? I mean all of them. Can’t stand them.
  • When Elsie comes to her mom in the kitchen, she MC is layered behind her mom, and it is a bit off, cuz it looks like her mom is petting her.
  • Your Instagram text overlay should be a tad lower, it’s not fully visible now.

3rd Episode

  • I love these little memories in the beginning. But this one got me thinking why does Elsie likes Oliver.
  • Check speechbubble in Piper-Oliver rant. When Piper is speaking, her speechbubble tail faces the wrong direction. Maybe check all convos and speechbubble positions, cuz I think I saw some more places too.
  • Piper is such a… I don’t have the word :DDDD Love how this innocent question turned out.
  • When mom is scolding MC, and then walks to her (upset), you make this “came closer” thing about the character position , not the size. To make her mom look like she is standing further than MC, you should’ve made MC bigger, but their eyes on more or less the same level. Check the guide.
Guide

image

  • When MC talks with Oliver in flower shop, it feels like their talking animations (without dialogue lines) are going for too long.

Okay. Overall.
This is one great story. Directing mostly is just perfect. Dialogues - insanely good and reflect realistic characters. I felt very invested in all that drama tbh. I think it is fair to say this is my favorite story from all the stories I have reviewed in this thread.
This deserves to be featured, like no doubt.
Hopefully you will :slight_smile: *Added to favorites

2 Likes

Oh my god I’m crying :sob: I’m gonna fix all the things you mentioned, thank you!

3 Likes

Just update fast woman :smiley: :laughing:

2 Likes

I’m trying :sob:

2 Likes

@writingwithjade - Echo Kreek


1st Episode

  • That Intro is quite intense.
  • When Elijah is walking from the police station he’s kinda walking down. Dunno. Maybe it would make sense to make him go to the side and getting bigger? I think it would look more realistic.
  • When MC is thanking Mauve the zoom kinda cuts MC’s half.
  • Is it intentionally that you people zoom so that parts of the character are cut? Maybe it’s just me obsessing over this.

2nd Episode

  • Owww. That dog is so cute ^^
  • Love how u worked with overlays. That fog is awesome.

3rd Episode

  • So the same thing I see as in the previous review. Instead of scaling characters, to make them look further, you just place them higher. Check the guide below. And I noticed you do it most of the time, with walking commands as well.
Guide

image

  • I don’t really understand the meaning of the choice about Alona. Like, readers already saw that she is shady and dislike Phyre. Makes the choice kinda obvious.

4th Episode

  • Um. I’m not sure, but I think you didn’t mention who we are allowed to customize. I suppose those all are love interests? Maybe it is worth mentioning.
  • reader message - “Shirley become interested”. I guess it is became
  • When Shirley is talking with Phyre, maybe u could try to do this over the shoulder directing thing? Cause it looks like Shirley is talking with her back turned to Phyre. For this stuff, I usually duplicate character, place them somewhere else in the background and just keep switching zones.
  • Yeah. TBH I’m not really sure what’s going on, I mean plot, but it’s not super-confusing, I just need more pieces of it. I suppose there’s a curse connected with the necklace. And Phyre seems to be cursed. Dunno why tho. And that lady in bloody clothes was hella creepy.
  • “I’m done”. This tab makes me giggle. I’m done :smiley:

5th Episode

  • “Egg.” :DDD What. Emily…

So overall. Dialogues are very good, smooth and differ from character to character. The plot is also good, unique and seems to be well written. Point system is cool. I think u know all of this :wink:
Directing mostly is great. You do well with zoom, overlays and basically everything.
Only issues I have with it are:

  1. Use of non-talking animations on dialogue lines, like laugh, eyeroll etc. I think I mention it in 85% of reviews.
  2. Zooms. Sometimes you cut characters, either horizontally or their heads. This is going throughout the story.
  3. Some walking to spot commands and perspective. I mentioned it in the comments for 3rd episode.
  4. I noticed a couple of time that you use one animation several times in a row. It might be okay with some of them, but if it is arms crossed animation, it is… kinda bugging?
    Otherwise, your story is great, and I really dunno how it doesn’t have more reads. I’d only advise updating more often, cause I think the 5th episode was coming for months.
    There wasn’t a lot I mentioned, but mostly cause everything was very solid.
    Good luck with ur story, hope it was helpful.
2 Likes

Thanks! I’m glad you liked it. I do need to go over the zooms/scaling in my directing and tenses in my sentences… I often times make those mistakes. It’s just so much code to go through! :sweat_smile: I definitely will go over that though, thanks for pointing that out!

Edit: Oh yeah, the two characters you’re able to customize are love interests, I should probably mention that as you said…

1 Like

Password: Evil Cookie
Title: Bad Behavior
Author: Liyah
Summary: How will Alana, Lucas, Ryan and Rachel survive their past and conquer their future…
If bad behavior follows them everywhere, they go?
Cover:

My main certain would be ways to improve. (If you spot any spelling errors or wrong usage of punctuation… That would be nice.)

I’m pretty sure you posted request before in my thread but didn’t use the right form, therefore was declined. Was it?

I don’t believe I was declined.
I do know that I deleted because I had some errors I wanted to fix before I got a review.

If u say so. Ok.

1 Like

Password: Evil Cookie
Title: The Jinxx Chronicles: Maces and Talons
Author: oakleafapprentice
Description: A different planet, a different world, and a different culture. Mysterious sects and a rebel leader just makes Ari’s job that much harder.
Small Cover:


The Main Concern: This is the first story I’m doing as a visual novel instead of an interactive one. It’s also the first one where I use a lot of different overlays and effects. I want to know if the flow is good, if the plot makes sense, and what can be improved on! It’s not published at the moment, so I’ll DM you a link. There’s a chapter and a half complete, more to be added soon!

1 Like

Shit I didn’t realize the password was part of the form… can I redo my entry for a review​:sob::sob::sob:

1 Like

Password: Evil Cookie
Title: Queen
Author: Steffi
Description: All her life, Devina was raised learning the ways of being a proper lady of the nobility. But her life is suddenly disrupted when a royal advisor visits and reveals to her that she is the next monarch of Artesia. WIll she reign? Or will she renounce her claim to the throne? Will she choose love or duty? It’s all up to you!!

What is the main concern about your story?: I would really like your complete honest thoughts on the writing, directing, and characters.

1 Like

I’ll add u

1 Like

Thank you :heart::heart::heart:

2 Likes

just want to let you know I haven’t forgotten! I am nearly done with all three episodes! i have one and two done and episode 3 is halfway done. as soon as i finish i will let you know and hopefully you can check it out. :smile: but no worries if you can’t get to it.

1 Like

I haven’t too, :joy::joy::joy: was slacking for a bit. Will try to do some reviews tomorrow

1 Like

Lol it’s ok nobody is paying you to do this so it’s on your time you’re schedule basically . I am going to try to hurry up because I really want to get your input on my story it was really helpful the last time

2 Likes

Thank you :slight_smile: :sunflower:

1 Like