I wrote a story and I'm worried... please help

The main character of my story was born as a boy, but she now has the body of a girl, so she is basically trans. The problem is that she “magically” became a woman (in the story I explain this better, but she literally has the body of a woman) and the whole story is about her transformation (just to clarify: the main focus is on her personality and maturity).

She is not just a trans character, gender dysphoria is part of her but she is a complex character. At first, she seems just feminine and nurturing, but once you know her story you realize how much she grew.

I wanted to change her identity and just make her a cis woman just to avoid backlash (because it’s a sensitive topic). Making her trans or cis doesn’t change the main plot, but I don’t want to censor myself.

The story plot is dark but nobody makes her feel bad for being trans. Only her mother and the LI know about this. I wrote her inspired by personal issues, I empathize with the trans community because they know how hard it is to perceive yourself in a different way just as I do (I never experienced the same things as them, so I know it’s not the same)

What do you think? Should I take a risk or just make her a cis woman?

1 Like

hello ! trans person here myself. this is certainly a very ambitious character arc you’re going for here. honestly in theory it sounds as though it could work ? obviously it’s entirely dependent on your writing itself, and how the universe this plot is set in develops, etc . i would be very, very careful with how you phrase specific things, though , especially if you are cis and don’t experience dysphoria yourself . if it doesn’t really affect the plotline or isn’t really relevant, though , i dont see why it would be necessary to add in at all (what does it bring to the story if the explanation of her backstory and struggles and dysphoria are only half-hearted ?) you wouldn’t want to seem as though this is performative representation lol . hope this helped a little !

3 Likes

Thank you for your honesty! I really respect trans people and that’s why I ask for your opinions. The thing is that she wants to change everything about herself and become a new person, gender dysphoria is just a part of that transformation, that’s why it doesn’t affect the plot if she is trans or not because she will become a new person anyways.

My original idea was making her trans but I reconsider it because as you say, I’m a cis woman and it’s a difficult topic. So I will wait for other answers.

1 Like

But as I said, I don’t want to disrespect trans people so if this offends you I’m not going to make her trans. I don’t like when people misrepresent Latinos so I’m not going to do this to another community…

The fact that I have “good intentions” doesn’t mean that I’m not going to mess up anything

I was also thinking about consulting a trans woman so I write a good character, but I don’t know

1 Like

Thank you! I will publish it once I decide if the MC is going to be trans or not

Personally I think it would be great to make the mc a trans character. It provides representation to the trans community. Especially if there’s no negative outlook (how the characters treat her, how she’s looked at, etc) because it 100% normalizes the idea of people being transgender (as the world should be). But then again, it’s totally up to you.

3 Likes

Heeyy trans guy here, I transitioned in 2016 and I find it great that you understand gender dysphoria is a part of trans people’s lively hood. What I would recommend is, be careful with your wordings and establishments!
The types of dysphoria what the trans person suffers from is also important; social dysphoria, physical dysphoria, and mental dysphoria. So it might affect the plot or how the trans person would view or think about things; so yes it will provide different struggles too.

Just because you’re a cis woman doesn’t mean you’re not allowed to write transgender folks in story, all it matters is that you have the right establishment ready and not harmful outlooks on transgender people including trans women; such as the objectivation or sexualization of transgender people throughout movies or novels that their only sheer of existence is to be this “diva s3x symbol” or s3x workers. (not saying we transgender folks can’t be s3x workers, I’m saying we’re always seen as one and that’s the only representation we get which is upsetting because we have a life of our own.)
These novels barely made us seem sane or possibly understood because our life existence is literally backed by science and we truly don’t deserve to be seen as not human.

Always remind the reader of the struggles of being transgender so they would understand that it’s truly a struggle and that you’re not writing a transgender MC for performative activism! A lot of people just throw out the term being transgender and that’s it, not throw in examples or feelings to the struggles.
A great example is as a trans guy you have to choose if you want to bind for more than 8 hours because of both your physical and social dysphoria; A transgender woman struggling to see herself passable because of her social and mental dysphoria.

Do NOT, and I repeat do NOT mention the MC’S deadname in a rude or outlandish manner. The amount of second-hand dysphoria I get whenever a transgender person gets misgendered or deadnamed purposefully is outlandish. Not saying it can’t be a part of a plot where MC is blackmailed or threatened for their own identity, I’m saying if you want a good representation for us trans folks, be equal when it comes to making us human and showing our oppression. Not everyone is gonna be a transphobe who deadnames the MC constantly; Some people make dead naming someone or misgendering someone a plot moving device which is straight-up wrong (It’s similar to LI saving MC from s3xual assault and making it a plot moving device)… It’s the bare minimum to respect trans folks and their identity, it doesn’t make anyone a hero for simply respecting someone’s existence to breathe or f*cking communicate lol.

Do NOT make MCs whole personality about being transgender ONLY, to make us human give us a literal personality instead of waddling around and making our identity our personality. Yes, our identity is a part of our lives just like you being a cis woman is and that it comes with its struggles, but making the whole concept only circling MC being transgender is the same level of making your favorite color your personality trait, like no I need know how the hell do you socialize with people and how your ratios and your boundaries because they’re scripted from your personality.
Take, for example, MC can be a woman which means she has her own personal and social struggles that come with her identity being a woman such as sexism and battling gender norms that define her cough her femininity, but does she make it her whole personality where all we see and talk about is her struggles of being a woman? No, what we either see in novels, stories, films or movies is how the MC intakes verbal social situations because it defines her personality as the MC.

That’s all I can think about writing a good transgender folk, and another reminder just because you’re cis doesn’t mean you can’t write a good transgender person in stories. Take the risk at this point because your intentions are pretty clear at this point, you want to put or shade light into normalizing transgender folks by making them MCs, and that you clearly want to be careful with what you personally write for these trans folks so you wouldn’t offend or misrepresent us as a community.

2 Likes

Thank you all for your answers! I prefer not making the MC a trans woman since it’s a very sensitive topic and I don’t want to include transphobia in my story (I created my own universe, so transphobia, racism, and homophobia don’t exist, I thought about another kind of problems).

Struggling with discrimination it’s part of being a trans person, that’s why I feel like it isn’t genuine to not include that. The good news is that I will try to find a trans woman interested in adapting the story and use my original idea. Giving her an opportunity to include her point of view will be much better, so I hope it works.

1 Like

So I’m trans (mtf) and I think it’s awesome you’re writing this story!!!
Some input: I came out as trans and lesbian to to my parents when I was 15. I had realized I was trans around middle school so it took some time for me to feel comfortable being trans myself and coming out. I am incredibly lucky that they support me, not all trans people are as lucky. Last summer (I’m 17 now) I began hormone therapy. I haven’t had surgery, but I would like to.
Many of the reactions to my transition have been positive, but not all. I have lost friends but I’ve also gained new friends within the lgbt+ community. It’s been a very hard journey but I am proud of who I am.
I am absolutely more than willing to answer any questions you have!

1 Like