A while ago I read this story (before profiles and backing-up existed lol) and I need help finding it. Basically the protagonist (in my case female) was an actress on a TV show or movie and she needed to pick between 4 guys in the beginning to be her on-screen love interest. To no surprise they end up actually having feeling for each other. I remember the character style was older/different too. The big cartoon-y eyes ones with big hair. It was not customizable.
Does anyone remember this?