Okay, so I just tried it a couple different ways and did get it working! I guess I’m mostly confused by the “from BLUEBUTTON” part. Maybe it’s just a coding strategy I’m just unaware of, but how I got it working was by just uploading my button overlay four times, and giving them different names (ie. BLUE BUTTON 1, BLUE BUTTON 2, etc.). Then you just set up your initial code as:
@overlay BLUE BUTTON 1 create AND overlay BLUE BUTTON 1 shifts to 31 23 in zone 1 AND overlay BLUE BUTTON 1 scales to 0.766 0.766 AND overlay BLUE BUTTON 1 moves to layer 1 AND overlay BLUE BUTTON 1 opacity 0 in 0