Two or less would be < 3 instead of < 2. Right now, you have 1 or less as your first condition.
Here’s a correct statement:
if (SUSPICIOUS < 3) {
POLICE OFFICER 2 (talk_neutral_loop_rear)
She said the truth
} elif (SUSPICIOUS > 2) [
POLICE OFFICER 2 (talk_neutral_loop_rear)
She lied
} else {
...
}
As for what @jar_output_error said, it’s true that the character points don’t reset. You can use the helper in the previewer to see and edit your points:
Story modifiers > character points > character