Poll of the Week: [Community Forum Thoughts]

community
mustreadstaffonly
poll-of-the-week

#1

Happy Autumn 2018 Episodians! Results are in from last week’s poll and it looks like Halloween is the part of Fall that you enjoy the most! And with an incredibly close second place :open_mouth:, with 53% of the votes…Hot chocolate and Chai Teas come in a well deserved second! Congrats to our winners :smiley:

This weeks poll is a little bit different as it’s regarding everyone’s favorite forums…our own! :scream:

Please let us know your honest opinions of what means the most to you when using the Episode Community Forums (What you would like to see the team focus most on) . Your opinion/vote count so please make sure to participate and leave us any of your related thoughts and questions below. If none of the available options are what is most important to you then please choose “Other” and write in your choice below :smiley:

Most Important (Episode Community Forum Edition)

  • Layout/Style/Theme (Physical attributes only. IE: Overlay, Location of forums/sub forums/menus, etc, forum background art. Anything to do with how the forums work and look visually)
  • Up-time & Availability (Forum status, are the forums always around and working when you need them?)
  • Content (The threads and post’s provided in the forums by the Episode Forum Team to keep the community active and happy. This goes for forum only contests, etc)
  • Features (Social Media integration, plugins, integrated forum games/badges/rewards)
  • Privacy & Security ( CAPTCHA, the flagging system, etc)
  • Other/Write-In Vote (Please list your favorite below and why)

0 voters


#2

#3

Hm…I think…another one would be…maybe supporting/appreciate the moderators of the forums. You guys are always on the look out for anything. Making sure things are set, straight, following rules, etc. My honest opinion.


#4

Is this the new place for polloftheweek @Jeremy


#5

Nope. The for poll of the week are always created in the correct sub forum based on the topic of the poll :slight_smile:


#6

oh ok


#7

Yes a discussion thread :smiley: (I didn’t quite understand the question at first, so maybe people haven’t discussed because it’s a bit confusing.)

While I fully understand why most people are voting for Content. The forums are usually a safe place, and it’s nice to have the forums that way. Especially when the community is always growing Content is definitely important, but I don’t think it needs all the attention. Forumers are always on the forums, and I guarantee it’s the forumers who flag most of the off topic / spam posts rather than the mods finding them. looks off in the distance to recall the days inwhich I spent at least 10 out of my 12 hours awake on the forums

However, I voted for Features because I think that features are what makes the forum fun. Yeah, the forum will have discussions and games and content, but badges or other prizes encourage forumers to participate. I also think that badges, plugins, rewards once in the forums will run themselves.


I don’t quite understand the Layout/Style/Theme option because I don’t know how much say the mods have in this topic? I’m going off an assumption but I don’t think the mods have the power to create new sub forums and such, and if they did, the forum is already nicely set up. Why would we need more subforums? (unless there’s a secret Fallen fanclub forum which I haven’t been invited to yet… the forum needs one of these if there isn’t already…) I do think I would love to see themed backgrounds and such, but again, that would probably require an art-team. (Hey, art competition on the forums? ‘Banner of the Month’?)


Up-time & Availability- I’ve only seen the forums down like four times and while it does seem that world is ending, I don’t think the focus should only be making sure the forums is online.


Privacy & Security - Yes…? I don’t quite get this…?


#8

Interestingly, I voted for Features too.

I did consider content before voting, but the way I see it… more posts by the Episode Forum Team probably won’t satisfy the community. Most times when a mod or admin starts a thread or even comments on someone else’s, there isn’t as much of a follow up as there is with our own threads. I mean, I don’t want to sound ungrateful, but sometimes it seems like we get given empty promises. It’s not something I’ve ever felt personally, but I’ve seen it around the forums and I imagine it does make people feel neglected.

Example of what I mean

The best example I can think of to explain what I mean is when all the talk of how contests actually work came up. I believe there’s been similar promises of an explanation about how …In My Bed!!! passed guidelines too. But I’m going to focus on the contest rubric one now…

There was lots of threads about this a while ago. Lots of discussions, lots of suggestions from forumers, etc. But back on May 5th on one of the posts, Liz said this:
We would like to know how the contests work
I know she went on maternity leave, so it wouldn’t have been hard for her to get back to this while she’s off, but the post does sort of make it sound like there was more than just her who were working on this… and she also did say it would be “out in a few weeks”.

For months, there was nothing on this… Until 8 days ago, this thread was made, which I’m assuming was their response, though there’s no official word on this so I could be wrong.
Episode Explained: Episode Grading Rubric

I’m almost 100% sure that everyone who wanted the contest rules explained probably has follow up questions or maybe just wants some clarification, but the thread was pinned and closed so there’s no possibility of a discussion or open dialogue.

I know this poll is only asking us what’s most important and not really asking what we want to see more of (therefore my entire point might seem irrelevant.), but with the majority voting for content, I don’t want the team to now focus all their energy on creating more content and neglecting this other stuff, especially when the team’s content could, excuse my disrespect, use improvement. I’d much rather see features get the attention instead.

So why I believe content from the Episode forum team won’t be helpful and thus shouldn’t be considered an important priority is because I don’t think it would actually keep the community happy. I think forumers would have a constant flow of questions and want replies and get frustrated when the team doesn’t reply. Or they’ll just be frustrated that the thread is pinned and closed so that no one can comment. Or they’ll be frustrated that the team makes topics about something different to what they specifically want. I just see this is a way to set up some false hopes if I’m honest…

I don’t mean this to be rude to the team, but I just think that the responsibilities they’ve got now is enough and don’t want to put pressure on the team to provide better content when there’s already quite a few of us regular forumers here that do a fine job of that already.


Why I voted for features is because, based on the little explanation provided in the brackets, it does sound like the one thing that has never really been incorporated into the forums.
I’m hoping by social media integration it means that they’ll work to make sure that forumers are treated the same as the insta community is, by making announcements here for things like the weekly shelves and beta-testing open calls too. I hope it doesn’t mean more contests that you can only enter with instagram (Dirty Dancing).

Integrated forum games/badges/rewards sounds really good too and it’s something I’d like to see, provided it’s done properly and gets followed through with. There was the forum badge contest when we first moved over to the new forums, and that kind of flopped :confused: So if this were to take more of a priority, I believe it would be something that would make the community come together, but also has the potential to disappoint the community too :frowning:


Also, I’m surprised layout/style/theme is coming second, considering the uproar when we moved over to the new forums. I know changing up the layout isn’t the exact same as it was when the old forums were deleted, but it would still be a change nontheless and there’s no way to change something and have everyone be happy with the changes.


#9