I have just spent a bit over an hour reading pretty much all the replies on this thread before presenting my own opinion.
I disagree with raising the age rating or making separate sections by age group. Those here who are supporting this are saying this because they believe that Episode is not following the guidelines and have stories inappropriate for 13 year olds and authors want to have more freedom with their writing.
First of all, I must clarify a misunderstanding that @Res seems to still hold. You can write about mature themes, but there are restrictions within that. I understand that you have spoken to an EPISODE staff member, however I would believe over the written and set guidelines from the company as a whole, rather than the one staff member. It could also be you understood the message differently, the staff member was trying to tell you to be cautious, or they straight up told you those things aren’t allowed.
These are the guidelines, copy/pasted:
promotes or depicts excessive violence or assault, including but not limited to sexual assault, murder, and torture against humans or animals;
any hate speech or content that promotes hatred or discrimination against individuals or groups, on the basis of race, ethnic or national origin, religion, marital status, disability, gender, age, or sexual orientation;
- promotes suicide, self-harm, abuse, or bullying;
- promotes excessive alcohol, tobacco or drug usage;
- promotes gambling, betting or casinos;
- portrays adult themes, including pornographic content, nudity, or prostitution; slanders or libels a person or third party;
- excessive use of profanity or sexually explicit phrases;
- advertises for outside products or services, including but not limited to website links, reviews, and promotional language;
- excessive promotion of the use of firearms, explosives, and ammunition; and excessive promotion of a political agenda.
You are allowed to have profanity as long as it isn’t excessive, you can include suicide, self-harm, abuse, bullying, alcohol, tobacco, drug usage, and gambling as long as you aren’t promoting such activities.
In regards to freedom concerning what an author may publish, an author can write a lot without making the story “kiddy”. There have been many stories on EPISODE that follow the guidelines set out by EPISODE that have darker themes, brilliant story lines, and amazing and mature lessons. If you would like me to name some, let me know.
In regard to the actual content on EPISODE, YES that is not appropriate for 13 year olds and under. Content that is inappropriate and violating guidelines is presented by EPISODE in official stories as well as user stories. EPISODE in fact, targets such audiences through ads that clearly violate their guidelines! Here, it is the community’s responsibility to hold EPISODE responsible for their actions and compel them to change the problematic areas. Although EPISODE removes many stories violating guidelines in the User section, they are unable to keep up with the amount. That is also a problem for Episode to solve by adding to their staff for moderation of content. Making sections by age sounds like a quick fix rather than solving the underlying problem of content violating guidelines being present on the app. OP’s goal of keeping inappropriate content out of young people’s hands is better achieved if EPISODE were to keep content violating their guidelines, off the app.
Here are problems that would come up if EPISODE were to have stories categorized by age group:
- The biggest problem and one that was brought up frequently: users lying about age.
By making different categories, it means that each category has it’s own set of guidelines to follow. Guidelines get more lax as the age category moves up. This means having an increase in stories that violate the current guidelines. Most users under 13 will lie about their age. This means that those users who have lied now have access to more inappropriate content than they do now. This is the opposite of OP’s goal.
- Determining which age category a story belongs to.
In the case of a User Story, the categorization of the story is dependent on the user. Obviously, EPISODE will not have the time or the staff to go through every each story to determine the age rating. This drastically increases chances of mature stories going into the wrong category. Again, young users who have been honest about their age will be exposed to stories inappropriate for their age. And if a moderation system is suggested in this case, let’s remember that there would be three different sections: 13-14. 15-17. and 18+. This means that EPISODE has to moderate all these sections. If EPISODE can’t handle the one 13+ section we currently have, how is EPISODE expected to make sure that all the stories on their app is in the appropriate section? This is, once again the opposite of OP’s goal and worsening EPISODE’s moderation system.
Overall, adding different age categories would be make the problem of inappropriate content on the app worse and we would go in the opposite direction of @Res goal. The best way to keep EPISODE safe for the current rating is for EPISODE and authors to uphold the guidelines set.
I had a few other reasons in my mind, but I can’t remember them right now.
If they come back to me, I will add on to this post.
I have an essay due tonight, but I feel like I wrote an essay on this post instead.